When I first saw those words, I thought that the way they were written didn't really flow the same as other things I have read from Selassie I, but that could be due to the translation into English. The person saying that it is not the words of His Majesty doesn't know that for sure. I would say that it has not been sufficiently proven that the words belong to Selassie I, but that doesn't mean He didn't say them.
I read some of the reasonings regarding those words, some people claim they are from a person named Edmund Jerome Vassell, the editor of iblack.ca. When I looked into the context of those words said by Edmund, he was claiming to quote Haile Selassie I, he was not claiming those to be his own words. Also, Mutabaruka put those words in a poem (attributing the speech to Selassie I) long before Edmund mentioned them, and I have also heard that those words were circulated in a book in the 80s or 90s.
This still doesn't prove that the words are from Haile Selassie I, but there is also no proof that the words are not from Haile Selassie I. Just because the words are not in the autobiographies, or books of speeches, doesn't mean they were not said. It was never claimed that the books of Haile Selassie I's speeches are the complete list of speeches (important utterances and selected speeches are the names of the books, so that would suggest it is only some of His speeches), and I have read some speeches in his autobiographies that were not in his books of speeches.
I have wondered in the past if I should not show that speech in my list of speeches, but have decided to keep it there for the time being.
|
|